Every organization has its heroes. In some industries, like mining and manufacturing, we know them well.

  • The leader who gets the call when production goes down and gets things running again.
  • The person who jumps on a plane whenever needed, works through the weekend and never seems to say, “No.”
  • The executive who delivers results, knows how to navigate the organization and has built strong relationships with senior leadership.

These people often deserve the recognition they receive. Organizations need people who can step up in a crisis, make decisions under pressure and go the extra mile when the situation requires it.

But there is a question we don’t ask often enough: What happens when heroics become our definition of high performance?

The people we celebrate send a powerful message about what it takes to succeed. Sometimes, that message is very different from the culture we say we want to create.

The paradox of the hero

Think about two leaders.

The first gets a call at 2 a.m. when a critical piece of equipment goes down. She mobilizes the right people, makes quick decisions and gets production running again.

Everyone knows what she accomplished. The impact is immediate and measurable.

Another leader has spent months looking at recurring failures, challenging maintenance practices and investing in root-cause analysis. Over time, the failures become less frequent.

No 2 a.m. phone call. No dramatic rescue. And, most importantly, not much of a story to tell at the next leadership meeting.

Which contribution is easier to recognize?

This is one of the paradoxes of prevention: when it works, nothing happens.

We see the same phenomenon in leadership.

The manager who works 70 hours a week and is personally involved in every important decision is highly visible. The one who builds a strong team and an organization capable of functioning without them may be much less so.

One creates visible effort. The other builds organizational capability.

Yet our performance systems, operational dashboards and even our own biases are often much better equipped to measure and value the first.

What we reward becomes our culture

Organizations today want to build cultures of collaboration, psychological safety, continuous improvement, accountability and diversity of thought.

But employees don’t learn culture primarily through the values on the wall. They watch what actually happens:

  • Who gets promoted and who gets listened to?
  • What behaviours are valued when performance is discussed?
  • Who is considered high potential?
  • And, perhaps most importantly, what do you have to do — and sometimes sacrifice — to succeed here?

These observations reveal the organization’s unwritten rules.

Social psychologist Mary Murphy describes two types of organizational cultures: a “Culture of Genius,” where individual contributors are more readily valued, and a “Culture of Growth,” where talent is seen as something that can be developed and where learning and collaboration contribute to performance.[1]

The parallel with the hero culture is interesting.

We don’t necessarily believe that talent can’t be developed, but we can behave as though exceptional performance comes primarily from exceptional individuals. We give them the toughest assignments and greater visibility. Over time, they become the people the organization can’t do without.

Meanwhile, the less visible work of building capability, developing others and improving the system receives less attention.

Employees notice… and they adapt.

This is how diversity of thought can quietly disappear

A growth-oriented culture doesn’t mean lowering expectations. It challenges how we think about performance.

An organization can work very hard to recruit people with different backgrounds, expertise and ways of thinking… and gradually filter that diversity out.

The continuous improvement leader who keeps asking why the same problem is happening may eventually be seen as slowing things down.

The organizational development leader advocating for investments that will take years to pay off may find her work dismissed as “soft” or “not strategic enough.”

The talented professional who wants to contribute at a high level but isn’t willing to sacrifice family life to get there may conclude that advancing in the organization simply isn’t compatible with the life they want.

Some leave. Others adapt their behaviour to fit the dominant model. And, perhaps more concerning, some eventually stop challenging.

The organization may retain diversity on paper while gradually losing the diversity of thought it was trying to create in the first place.

Changing our heroes requires changing the system

Culture won’t change simply because we ask leaders to collaborate more or encourage employees to speak up. We need to examine what our systems actually reinforce.

The approach we recommend at Brio Management focuses on three levers.

  1. REVEAL the implicit definition of success

Look beyond your stated leadership competencies.

  • Who actually advances?
  • Who gets the most important assignments?
  • Which successes become the stories the organization tells?
  • Which behaviours do we tolerate because someone “delivers results”?

The answers often tell us much more about the real culture than the values on the wall.

  1. REALIGN how we measure performance

If leaders are evaluated almost exclusively on production, costs and short-term results, we shouldn’t be surprised when they focus primarily on the short term.

Those measures remain essential. But so do the things that make performance sustainable: prevention, continuous improvement, talent development, cross-functional collaboration and the ability to solve problems at the source.

The answer isn’t to add a dozen “soft” KPIs. It’s to ask whether our scorecards measure the performance the organization needs today and tomorrow, and to include a few measures of HOW results are achieved, not just WHAT gets delivered.

  1. REINFORCE a broader definition of success

Promotion and recognition are probably among the most powerful cultural mechanisms in any organization. The people we promote show everyone else what successful leadership looks like here.

So we need to broaden our definition of the “hero.”

Let’s also celebrate the leader who prevents the crisis, the one who builds a team capable of operating without them, the person who raises a risk before it becomes an incident, and the manager who prepares others to take on greater responsibilities.

This may be where the shift from a hero culture to a growth culture matters most.

It doesn’t mean exceptional individual performance stops mattering. It means broadening our definition of exceptional performance to include the ability to make the system, and the people around us, better.

Heroics will always have a place in organizations, particularly in mining and manufacturing. Some situations genuinely require someone to step up and solve the immediate problem.

But heroics should be an exceptional capability the organization can draw on, not the operating model it depends on.

If you want to understand your real culture, don’t start with your values.

Look at your heroes.

[1] Mary C. Murphy (2024), Cultures of Growth: How the New Science of Mindset Can Transform Individuals, Teams, and Organizations, Simon & Schuster.

 

Written by: Myriam Levert

Share

Want to understand your culture? Look at your heroes.